Loading...
Thumbnail Image
Item

Probability judgements about indicative conditionals : An erotetic theory

Citations
Google Scholar:
Altmetric:
Principal Supervisor
Co-Supervisor
Degree Name
Abstract
Research into the cognition of conditionals has predominantly focused on conditional reasoning, producing a range of theories which explain associated phenomena with considerable success. However, such theories have been less successful in accommodating experimental data concerning how agents assess the probability of indicative conditionals. Since an acceptable account of conditional reasoning should be compatible with evidence regarding how we evaluate conditionals' likelihoods, this constitutes a failing of such theories. Section 1 introduces the most dominant established approach to conditional reasoning: mental models theory. Surveying a range of experimental results, I show that mental models theory (along with competing theories) is incapable of fully accounting for findings regarding judgements about conditionals' probabilities. Section 2 introduces an alternative account of deductive reasoning, the erotetic theory, recently proposed by Koralus and Mascarenhas (2013). Section 3 argues that, given a natural extension, this theory is able to explain the otherwise unaccounted for data.
Keywords
probabilistic reasoning, indicative conditionals, erotetic theory of reasoning, mental models
Publication Date
2016
Type
Journal article
Published In
Logic Journal of the IGPL
Volume
24
Issue
4
Article Number
Start page
End page
Page Range
600-611
ACU Organisational Area
Dianoia Institute of Philosophy
Faculty of Theology and Philosophy
Related
Open Access Status
File Access
Controlled
License
All rights reserved
License Link
Rights Statement
ICIP
Funded By
Full Citation
Further Information