Loading...
Beneficent governor of the cosmos : Kant and Sidgwick on the moral necessity of god
Author
Principal Supervisor
Co-Supervisor
Degree Name
Abstract
Kant and Sidgwick agree that genuine ethical principles must be sourced in reason rather than divine commands. Yet, despite sharing this secular starting point, both philosophers ultimately conclude that the assumption of God’s existence is necessary for the complete viability of practical reason (including principles of morality) within human beings. This mutual reintroduction of God is especially surprising given that Kant and Sidgwick advocate divergent moral theories. The central claim of this chapter is that, despite their philosophical differences, Kant’s and Sidgwick’s respective appeals to the moral necessity of God have a common cause. Both philosophers perceive a deep human need to believe in cosmic justice (i.e., universal harmony between duty and happiness), and their shared hedonic account of well-being colors their conception of what such justice must involve. After explaining how these ideas give rise to the ostensible moral need for faith, I provide a brief defense of an alternative view based on the Stoic belief that the universe is ultimately just, despite the lack of a reliable connection between moral virtue and hedonic well-being.
Keywords
Publication Date
2020
Type
Book chapter
Published In
Kantian and Sidgwickian ethics : The cosmos of duty above and the moral law within
Volume
Issue
Article Number
Start page
End page
Page Range
210-244
ACU Organisational Area
Faculty of Education and Arts
Collections
ACU Research Bank Link
Related
Open Access Status
File Access
Controlled
License
All rights reserved
