Loading...
Similar but different : Differences in comprehension diagnosis on the Neale Analysis of Reading Ability and the York Assessment of Reading for Comprehension
Principal Supervisor
Co-Supervisor
Degree Name
Abstract
Background
Identifying reading comprehension difficulties is challenging. There are many comprehension tests to choose from, and a child's diagnosis can be influenced by various factors such as a test's format and content and the choice of diagnostic criteria. We investigate these issues with reference to the Neale Analysis of Reading Ability (NARA) and the York Assessment of Reading for Comprehension (YARC).
Methods
Ninety-five children were assessed on both tests. Test characteristics were compared using Principal Components and Regression analyses as well as an analysis of passage content.
Results
NARA comprehension scores were more dependent on decoding skills than YARC scores, but children answered more comprehension questions on the NARA and passages spanned a wider range of difficulty. Consequently, 15–34% of children received different diagnoses across tests, depending on diagnostic criteria.
Conclusion
Knowledge of the strengths and weaknesses of comprehension tests is essential when attempting to diagnose reading comprehension difficulties.
Keywords
Publication Date
2017
Type
Journal article
Published In
Journal of Research in Reading
Volume
40
Issue
4
Article Number
Start page
End page
Page Range
403-419
ACU Organisational Area
Faculty of Education and Arts
Collections
ACU Research Bank Link
Related
Open Access Status
Published as green open access
File Access
Controlled
Open
Open
