Loading...
Neurodevelopmental outcome at 5 years of age after general anaesthesia or awake-regional anaesthesia in infancy (GAS) : An international, multicentre, randomised, controlled equivalence trial
Author
McCann, Mary Ellen
de Graaff, Jurgen C.
Dorris, Liam
Disma, Nicola
Withington, Davinia
Bell, Graham
Grobler, Anneke
Stargatt, Robyn
Hunt, Rodney W.
Sheppard, Suzette J.
Marmor, Jacki
Giribaldi, Gaia
Bellinger, David C.
Hartmann, Penelope L.
Hardy, Pollyanna
Frawley, Geoff
Izzo, Francesca
von Ungern Sternberg, Britta S.
Lynn, Anne
Wilton, Niall
Mueller, Martin
Polaner, David M.
Absalom, Anthony R.
Szmuk, Peter
Morton, Neil
Berde, Charles
Soriano, Sulpicio
Davidson, Andrew J.
Frawley, Geoff
Hardy, Pollyanna
Arnup, Sarah
Grobler, Anneke
Lee, Katherine
Hunt, Rod W.
Stargatt, Robyn
Sheppard, Suzette J.
Ormond, Gillian D.
Hartmann, Penelope L.
Takagi, Michael J.
Taylor, Kaitlyn
Malarbi, Stephanie
Doyle, Melissa
Ragg, Philip
Costi, David
von Ungern-Sternberg, Britta
Wilton, Niall C.
Knottenbelt, Graham
Withington, Davinia
Furue, Koto
Gagnon, Hélène
Disma, Nicola
Mameli, Leila
Giribaldi, Gaia
Pini Prato, Alessio
Mattioli, Girolamo
Wolfler, Andrea
Izzo, Francesca
Bova, Stefania M.
Krachmalnicoff, Arianna
Guuva, Claudia
de Graaff, Jurgen C.
van der Werff, Desiree B. M.
van Gool, Jose T. D. G.
van Loon, Kim
Kalkman, Cor J.
van Baar, Anneloes L.
Absalom, Anthony R.
Hoekstra, Frouckje M.
Volkers, Martin
Oostra, Martine
Bell, Graham
Dorris, Liam
Morton, Neil S.
Pownall, Jaycee
Waldman, Jack
Hind, Ruth
Symonds, Joseph D.
Bagshaw, Oliver
McCann, Mary Ellen
Berde, Charles
Soriano, Sulpicio
Sethna, Navil
Kovatsis, Pete
Cravero, Joseph
Bellinger, David
Marmor, Jacki
Lynn, Anne
Ivanova, Iskra
Hunyady, Agnes
Verma, Shilpa
Polaner, David
Thomas, Joss
Mueller, Martin
Haret, Denisa
Szmuk, Peter
Steiner, Jeffrey
Kravitz, Brian
Farrow-Gillespie, Alan
Suresh, Santhanam
Hays, Stephen
Taenzer, Andreas
Maxwell, Lynne
Williams, Robert
de Graaff, Jurgen C.
Dorris, Liam
Disma, Nicola
Withington, Davinia
Bell, Graham
Grobler, Anneke
Stargatt, Robyn
Hunt, Rodney W.
Sheppard, Suzette J.
Marmor, Jacki
Giribaldi, Gaia
Bellinger, David C.
Hartmann, Penelope L.
Hardy, Pollyanna
Frawley, Geoff
Izzo, Francesca
von Ungern Sternberg, Britta S.
Lynn, Anne
Wilton, Niall
Mueller, Martin
Polaner, David M.
Absalom, Anthony R.
Szmuk, Peter
Morton, Neil
Berde, Charles
Soriano, Sulpicio
Davidson, Andrew J.
Frawley, Geoff
Hardy, Pollyanna
Arnup, Sarah
Grobler, Anneke
Lee, Katherine
Hunt, Rod W.
Stargatt, Robyn
Sheppard, Suzette J.
Ormond, Gillian D.
Hartmann, Penelope L.
Takagi, Michael J.
Taylor, Kaitlyn
Malarbi, Stephanie
Doyle, Melissa
Ragg, Philip
Costi, David
von Ungern-Sternberg, Britta
Wilton, Niall C.
Knottenbelt, Graham
Withington, Davinia
Furue, Koto
Gagnon, Hélène
Disma, Nicola
Mameli, Leila
Giribaldi, Gaia
Pini Prato, Alessio
Mattioli, Girolamo
Wolfler, Andrea
Izzo, Francesca
Bova, Stefania M.
Krachmalnicoff, Arianna
Guuva, Claudia
de Graaff, Jurgen C.
van der Werff, Desiree B. M.
van Gool, Jose T. D. G.
van Loon, Kim
Kalkman, Cor J.
van Baar, Anneloes L.
Absalom, Anthony R.
Hoekstra, Frouckje M.
Volkers, Martin
Oostra, Martine
Bell, Graham
Dorris, Liam
Morton, Neil S.
Pownall, Jaycee
Waldman, Jack
Hind, Ruth
Symonds, Joseph D.
Bagshaw, Oliver
McCann, Mary Ellen
Berde, Charles
Soriano, Sulpicio
Sethna, Navil
Kovatsis, Pete
Cravero, Joseph
Bellinger, David
Marmor, Jacki
Lynn, Anne
Ivanova, Iskra
Hunyady, Agnes
Verma, Shilpa
Polaner, David
Thomas, Joss
Mueller, Martin
Haret, Denisa
Szmuk, Peter
Steiner, Jeffrey
Kravitz, Brian
Farrow-Gillespie, Alan
Suresh, Santhanam
Hays, Stephen
Taenzer, Andreas
Maxwell, Lynne
Williams, Robert
Principal Supervisor
Co-Supervisor
Degree Name
Abstract
Background
In laboratory animals, exposure to most general anaesthetics leads to neurotoxicity manifested by neuronal cell death and abnormal behaviour and cognition. Some large human cohort studies have shown an association between general anaesthesia at a young age and subsequent neurodevelopmental deficits, but these studies are prone to bias. Others have found no evidence for an association. We aimed to establish whether general anaesthesia in early infancy affects neurodevelopmental outcomes.
Methods
In this international, assessor-masked, equivalence, randomised, controlled trial conducted at 28 hospitals in Australia, Italy, the USA, the UK, Canada, the Netherlands, and New Zealand, we recruited infants of less than 60 weeks' postmenstrual age who were born at more than 26 weeks' gestation and were undergoing inguinal herniorrhaphy, without previous exposure to general anaesthesia or risk factors for neurological injury. Patients were randomly assigned (1:1) by use of a web-based randomisation service to receive either awake-regional anaesthetic or sevoflurane-based general anaesthetic. Anaesthetists were aware of group allocation, but individuals administering the neurodevelopmental assessments were not. Parents were informed of their infants group allocation upon request, but were told to mask this information from assessors. The primary outcome measure was full-scale intelligence quotient (FSIQ) on the Wechsler Preschool and Primary Scale of Intelligence, third edition (WPPSI-III), at 5 years of age. The primary analysis was done on a per-protocol basis, adjusted for gestational age at birth and country, with multiple imputation used to account for missing data. An intention-to-treat analysis was also done. A difference in means of 5 points was predefined as the clinical equivalence margin. This completed trial is registered with ANZCTR, number ACTRN12606000441516, and ClinicalTrials.gov, number NCT00756600.
Findings
Between Feb 9, 2007, and Jan 31, 2013, 4023 infants were screened and 722 were randomly allocated: 363 (50%) to the awake-regional anaesthesia group and 359 (50%) to the general anaesthesia group. There were 74 protocol violations in the awake-regional anaesthesia group and two in the general anaesthesia group. Primary outcome data for the per-protocol analysis were obtained from 205 children in the awake-regional anaesthesia group and 242 in the general anaesthesia group. The median duration of general anaesthesia was 54 min (IQR 41–70). The mean FSIQ score was 99·08 (SD 18·35) in the awake-regional anaesthesia group and 98·97 (19·66) in the general anaesthesia group, with a difference in means (awake-regional anaesthesia minus general anaesthesia) of 0·23 (95% CI −2·59 to 3·06), providing strong evidence of equivalence. The results of the intention-to-treat analysis were similar to those of the per-protocol analysis.
Interpretation
Slightly less than 1 h of general anaesthesia in early infancy does not alter neurodevelopmental outcome at age 5 years compared with awake-regional anaesthesia in a predominantly male study population.
Funding
US National Institutes of Health, US Food and Drug Administration, Thrasher Research Fund, Australian National Health and Medical Research Council, Health Technologies Assessment–National Institute for Health Research (UK), Australian and New Zealand College of Anaesthetists, Murdoch Children's Research Institute, Canadian Institutes of Health Research, Canadian Anesthesiologists Society, Pfizer Canada, Italian Ministry of Health, Fonds NutsOhra, UK Clinical Research Network, Perth Children's Hospital Foundation, the Stan Perron Charitable Trust, and the Callahan Estate.
Keywords
Publication Date
2019
Type
Journal article
Published In
The Lancet
Volume
393
Issue
10172
Article Number
Start page
End page
Page Range
664-677
ACU Organisational Area
ACU Research Bank Link
Related
Open Access Status
Published as ‘gold’ (paid) open access
File Access
Open
License
CC BY 4.0
